Macquarie Network ::: 2GB | LIVENEWS | STREET CORNER | RUGBYLEAGUELIVE | WHAT CAREER | AMAZING AUSTRALIANS :::
RugbyLeagueLive.com logo

McKinnon got off lightly: Gallop, coaches

 

Peter Cassidy | 05/09/08 | 0

 

NRL boss David Gallop has slammed the three match ban imposed on Wade McKinnon for spitting at a touch judge, insisting it was too lenient and demanding harsher penalties for players caught disrespecting match officials.

The Warriors have a different take on the matter, claiming the penalty is unfair after their application to appeal was thrown out by judiciary chairman Greg Woods.

Unsurprisingly, rival NRL coaches have sided with Gallop.

Speaking with News Limited, Gallop said: "We fully support the process and the jury of ex-players making a decision but in this case, on the face of it, the penalty appears to be too light."

While the NRL won't step in on this occasion, Gallop has warned of actions which could influence future cases.

"The NRL board has an ability to make a directive regarding future judiciary issues," Gallop told News Limited

"As there is a board meeting (today), we will be recommending that where there is a clear finding of a player spitting at an official, we would expect a suspension of months, not weeks. Therefore this case will not necessarily operate as a precedent into the future."

Gold Coast coach John Cartwright is amongst those supporting Gallop's stance, insisting the penalty should have been months, not weeks.

"It sends a poor message to everyone involved in the game," Cartwright told News Limited.

"I'd rather be punched in the head than spat on. Spitting on a touch judge - it should be eight weeks minimum. What's the next bloke going to get?"

Penrith steer Matt Elliott agreed.

"He (McKinnon) is lucky. If our game has a standard punishment that says if you spit at a touch judge, you get three weeks, then that's too lenient.

"He should buy a 'scratchy'."

He should buy a 'scratchy'... Penrith coach Matt Elliott

 
 
Make a Comment

Comments

5/09/2008 3:06:56 AM If McKinnon had of actually spat ON the touch judge then I agree that he should have been suspended for months, but the fact that a player was suspended for looking at a touch judge while spitting at the ground is a disgrace.

What action is the NRL taking against the atrocious decisions being made week in week out by referees, touch judges and video referees? Posted by: Brendan Legg, Brisbane, Australia Reply

5/09/2008 4:43:46 AM C'mon Brendan, fair crack of the whip. If the spit had hit the touch judge he should of got years and not months. Because he missed he is lucky and should have got 2 months. 3 games, 2 of which will be trial games is a joke. Spitting is a grubs act, if he was a member of the public and that was a police officer he would be close to going to jail.

The atrocious decisions of a touch judge have no relevance to this decision either Posted by: Kieran Willey, Townsville, Australia Reply

5/09/2008 9:31:36 AM Wade treads a fine line with officials and I thought he would be suspended. I knew he would have been made an example of. I am surprised however that the sentence was that small and also that he was found guilty on the lack of eveidence and yet Hilder got nothing for what he did only because 'they weren't sure if he meant to spit in the other players face'. Seems a bit inconsistant here. They both should have been banned or neither of them banned. This makes the judiciary look like a farce. Posted by: Glenn Wrack, Auckland, Other Reply

 

Comment


 

 

 
 

 
 
500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.
 
 

* Required field

 

Send to friend


 

 

 

 

 

 
 
500 characters maximum. 500 characters left.
 

* Required field

 
 
 
CLOSE
 

Lorem ipsum dolor sit amet, consectetur adipisicing elit, sed do eiusmod tempor incididunt ut labore et dolore.

New user?

 
 

Existing user?

Forgot your password?

CLOSE
 

Forgot your password?

Please enter the email address you registered with:

 

Back to login

 
You must have flash installed to view this site.
Feedback  |   Where to hear  |   Schedule

More Highlights

Highlights

Steve 'Blocker' Roach's World Cup wrap

EXCLUSIVE FIRST INTERVIEW: Ray Hadley with Daniel Anderson

The Moore Report: Critics write off Raiders...again

The Continuous Call Team at birth

CCT TV: Weekend Detention


 
 
 
 
 

Your Say

Good point digger Friend has established himself as their No. 1 Hooker It goes to show you that no... Anthony Tassone, Hornsby, Australia on Robbie Farah Gold Coast bound

why the hell are titans after either!?? Friend is a machine... digger d, sydney, Australia on Robbie Farah Gold Coast bound

Your outburst has embarrassed you team and country, you have shown that rather than take defeat on t... OUST DOUST, Sydney, Australia on Sorry may not cut it for under-fire Stuart

Ed you speak about skirting the facts. I notice that you have mentioned that Australia is beter than... Kiwi Fan, Auckland, Other on I didn't cost us the World Cup: Slater

I am sick to death of everyone skirting the facts. The Australian players have more talent and are ... Eel Nut, Sydney, Australia on I didn't cost us the World Cup: Slater

Klein should apologise for being the worst referee in history last Saturday night. K B, Brisbane, Australia on Sorry may not cut it for under-fire Stuart

 
Most Commented
 
 
 
 

LATEST FEATURES

'Tough guys': Dragons try on their new reputation
Bennett defends Stuart, declines top job
Robbie Farah Gold Coast bound
Craig Wing facing surgery fears
Slater claims Golden Boot
Peacock's family stranded in Bangkok